Last summer, I found a deal on cherries at a local market. My eldest daughter and I spent the evening pitting and canning up quarts of cherries for future use. We even saved the pits to make cherry extract. Which my husband calls cough syrup.
This past weekend we were going to a dinner with friends, and we were asked to bring a dessert. Always tired of making the same thing over and over again I began thumbing through an old cookbook that was acquired from my Great Aunt Sue (I knew this cookbook had lots of recipes utilizing lard, which we rendered on earlier in the week I included the link if anyone is interested in that process).

In it I found a folded piece of paper with a cherry pie recipe on it. Having all the ingredients we decided to give it a try.
Ingredients for the filling:
3 Cans (16 oz each) of Tart Cherries Drained
1/2 C Juice retained from the cherries
1 C Sugar
1/4 C Quick cooking tapioca
1 TBSP lemon juice
1/2 tsp Almond extract
Dash of salt

As we had already put-up cherries, we chose to use those rather than go to the store we drained 1 qt and 1 pt. Starting by draining the cherries into a bowl.
Dont forget to save 1/2 C of cherry juice.

In another bowl mix together all other filling ingredients and let sit for 20 minutes.


This filling is supposed to be enough for two 9 inch pies, I have discovered using 9-1/2 in pie plates it makes one pie. Use your favorite pie crust to line your pie plate.


Pre-Heat the oven to 400 degrees. My helper would like to show off his counter cleaning skills.

While the pie is in the oven (35 min at 400 degrees) it is time to make the Streusel topping.
Ingredients for topping:
3/4 C Flour
1/2 C Packed brown sugar
2 tsp cinnamon
1/3 C cool butter, cut in to chunks

Mix together with a fork or a pastry knife until blended and crumbly

After baking for 35 minutes, top the pie with the streusel and continue baking for another 10 minutes. Remove when it is bubbly!

Make sure that you let your pie fully cool before cutting. Everyone at the party gave it great reviews. I hope you enjoy it too!
This sounds incredible! There is something so special about finding old handwritten recipes. I’m sure your cherries were a million times better than canned ones! 🙂
LikeLike